cakewalkKaKed wrote: ↑Fri Oct 06, 2017 12:43 pm
yes it is,an acoustic neck has more mass over a shorter length = strong
Are seriously trying to wind every one up?
An acoustic guitar neck has no more or less mass than an electric guitar neck. There are acoustic guitars that have significantly less mass than many electric guitars. There are acoustic guitars necks that have more mass than electric guitar necks. Unfortunately mass of the neck has zero to do with this...
say an SG = its bendy
"Bendy" is not a recognised scientific term. If you mean "elastic" an SG neck is made from the same materials the same as any other mahogany neck. The reason they are famous for not holding tune has nothing to do with the truss rod.
you can also put a bow in a neck ..
I have no idea why you would want to do that but whatever.. What you might want to do is add relief to a neck set. That isnt putting a "bow" in a neck that is partially compensating for the tension in the strings and resulting tension applied at the back of the neck to nearly but not quite restore it to its original position. A truss rods sole purpose is to counteract any bow in the neck not introduce one.. Again it is totally not the fix to the problem being discussed.
what about the headstock position when all this counter tensions going on?
What about it? I have no idea what you are attempting to propose...?
and that's not also the nut relation to the bridge .. and say the 24th fret?
I have no idea what this is supposed to mean either.
a guitar neck is only fixed at one end,to do what your talking about it must be fixed at both ends
The only thing applying force to the fingerboard is the truss rod. It has nothing to do with how a neck is fixed.
We are discussing truss rods. The equivalent scientific analysis on how they behave is as a fixed beam. A truss rod behaves as a fixed beam. The neck is not applying the force, it is attempting to maintain equilibrium under the pull of the strings which incidentally are anchored at both ends.
The more you type the more you show me that you havent grasped the fundamental principles of what is going on with a neck and the forces that act on it.